The impacts of climate change on poverty and humanitarian crises: what observations and proposals from civil society?

©Yann Castanier/Forum Mondial Convergences

As part of the 10th Convergences World Forum, we had the pleasure of co-organising a conference in partnership with the French Red Cross Fund, entitled:

“Impacts of climate change on poverty and humanitarian crises: what observations and proposals from civil society?”

As the President of the French Red Cross Fund, Professor Jean-François Mattei, recalled in his opening speech, our two organisations have common goals, especially that of “building bridges between the operational world on the field and the academic world, between the Anglo-Saxon and Francophone worlds, and […] accompanying ‘humanitarian transition’”.

For the second year in a row, Humanitarian Alternatives and the French Red Cross Fund presented “atypical” subjects at Convergences(1)In 2016, Humanitarian Alternatives endeavoured to analyse how humanitarian aid substituted for political weaknesses in the face of forced migrations (to see the full conference, click here) and the French Red Cross Fund organised a conference on insurance against risks of cataclysms and disasters of all kinds (Insurance against the risk of crisis: a path towards humanitarian transition?” To see the full conference, click here).. With this conference, which was held on Tuesday September 5th 2017, we united with the objective of presenting the impacts of climate change on poverty and humanitarian crises.

Speakers:

●      Mrs. Claire FEHRENBACH – General Director, OXFAM France, Paris
●      Mr. Benoît HAZARD – Anthropologist and research fellow at the CNRS and the EHESS, joint editor-in-chief of the Cahiers d’études africaines, Paris
●      Mr. Cheikh KANE – Consultant in climate resilience for West Africa, Red Cross/Red Crescent Climate Centre, Paris
●      Pr. Jeannot RAMIARAMANANA – Director of the Centre For Economics and Ethics for the Environment and Development at the University of Antananarivo and scientific advisor for the research programme UMI-Resiliences-IRD, Madagascar

The conference was moderated by Stéphanie STERN, head of the Lab Project, Action Contre la Faim, Paris

Context

In 2014, the fifth report(2)http://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar5/wg1/index_fr.shtml by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) highlighted the evaluation of socio-economic aspects linked to climate change, and the consequences in terms of sustainable development, regional aspects, risk management and the establishment of a framework for intervention based on methods of adaptation and integration: an increase in under nutrition rates in Africa, redoubled causes of vulnerability for poor populations, a recrudescence of “natural” disasters linked to climate…

In 2015, on the eve of the COP21 in Paris, a report from the World Bank confirmed the link between climate and poverty, with one of the authors stating that “climate change represents a threat for the eradication of poverty, but its impacts on poverty by 2030 will be determined in large part by political choices: rapid, inclusive development which integrates the risks of climate change may prevent most impacts on the short term, however, 100 million more people may be poor in 2030 because of climate change, if adequate development policies are not adopted”. These projects should foremost concern political and economic actors, but they also raise questions regarding the still-distant relationship between humanitarian, environmental and development NGOs, in the West and in the Global South.

Faced with this injunction presented by the climatic agenda, can these three categories of NGOs remain, as we too often observe, confined to their respective fields, or ought they not finally ensure that they work together in field actions, coordinate their partnerships and lead common advocacy initiatives? This debate, which took place as France announced a decrease in development aid and the United States withdrew from the Paris Climate Agreement, was the opportunity to share their observations and proposals.

Bringing humans back to the forefront of concerns

The acceleration and intensification of natural disasters places the question of the impact of climate change at the centre of the debate. We can observe an undeniable increase in temperatures, a heightened frequency of extreme natural events, and a rise in pollution levels which threaten to become even more harmful than those of the pre-industrial era. All of these factors will indisputably have an impact on the local economies of the most vulnerable countries.

The example of Madagascar

Madagascar is an island which has been struck hard by cyclones. The largely agricultural country (¾ of the population) is heavily dependent on the climate. However, a number of factors limit the country’s capacity to face up to climate change: the precarious health system, the population’s low level of education (40% of adults are illiterate), insufficient financial means, the fragility of political institutions, the demographic curve, the bad management and exploitation of natural resources…

These factors all mean that the country is currently under threat.

Benoit Hazard believes that in order to face up to the consequences of climate change, the problem must no longer be analysed from the angle of the geosciences, but must focus on human, social and public structures. In the same way, Professor Jeannot Ramiaramanana insisted that climate change must not remain a purely scientific issue but that mankind must be at the centre of concerns. He called for the application of the principle of precaution and of shared, yet differentiated, responsibility, recalling that “we have all – to different degrees – participated in climate change and we must all, at our respective levels, take control of the responsibility according to our capacity for action”. Today, “the issue is no longer that of pointing the finger at those who are most responsible, but taking into account the needs of each community”, and respecting the principles of justice, equality and solidarity.

What international mobilisation?

At the international level, the USA’s withdrawal from the Paris Agreement and the unfinished discussions regarding the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions reveal a lack of international mobilisation and coherence in the face of this problem, which must be considered to be global. According to Professor Jeannot Ramiaramanana, it is necessary to favour an approach based on the means at the disposal of the international community in order to confront climate change. Scientists are bound by their “duty to the truth”, and aid actors by the implementation of ethical principles and the taking into account of each party’s needs and capacities to reduce the effects of climate change.

The example of a mobilisation: Oxfam

Oxfam is a confederation of 20 affiliates working in 90 countries. Oxfam’s mission is to combat the inequalities which exacerbate poverty, with the goal of eradicating it.
At Oxfam, the question of climate change is seen from the angle of poverty, and more specifically, of food security, and is based on the observation that climate change provokes natural disasters which will have an impact on crops and farming and therefore on food production. According to the association’s estimates, the average price of food with increase by 140% by 2030, and this increase will directly affect the most vulnerable populations. By 2050, more than 20% of the population will suffer from food scarcity.
In the field, Oxfam acts on the total system of food and water supplies, and on issues of sanitation. The association also provides food assistance, shelter and emergency kits.
Oxfam works with concerned populations on different issues such as the creation of grain stocks, the revitalisation of mangroves – which enable the development of biodiversity and, in case of typhoons, hold back water -, early warning systems, the reinforcement of resilience capacities, risk prevention, etc.
In France, Oxfam carries out important advocacy work by publishing reports, raising awareness amongst the general public, and calling for mobilisation in order to influence decision-makers and demand ambitious policy commitments.
To learn more about Oxfam’s actions, click here.

Moreover, Claire Fehrenbach recalls the creation, in 2009, of the Green Climate Fund, during the Copenhagen Summit, wherein countries agreed to engage 100 billion dollars by 2020, a part of which was to be hosted by the Green Fund, making it the primary channel for “climate funding”. Yet the Fund collected only 10 billion between 2015 and 2018, out of the 100 billion that were initially pledged.

A number of tensions exist regarding the circulation of funding, and the complex accreditation system put in place in order to define the distribution of funding. Claire Fehrenbach decries the absence of an “exclusion” list to prevent the funding of harmful projects. As an example, the GIEC experts agree that 80% of fossil fuel resources must remain in the subsoil in order to avoid rising temperatures. Yet nothing in the Green Fund’s regulations excludes projects based on fossil fuels. On the contrary, some of the banks which enable the circulation of this funding invest in this sector…

The coming challenges

A question which is becoming increasingly important to answer concerns the link between climate change, conflict and forced displacement. Cheikh Kane, from the Climate Centre, points out that this question must be clearly addressed and systematically taken into account by states. He reminds us that forced migrations due to the impacts of climate change fall into a legal vacuum, since there is no status for “climate refugees”. Hence, in this context, the Climate Centre is committed to this question and is endeavouring to replace it at the centre of the debate by appealing to international humanitarian law. Cheikh Kane points out that climate change exacerbates conflicts around natural resources, which forces populations to migrate. However, unlike the refugee status, the difficulty of this potential status lies in the identification of the source of the pressure, which gives rise to real limits in terms of responsibility and accountability.

The Climate Centre is a specialised reference centre and part of the International Federation of the Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, based in the Netherlands. Its mission is to allow the Red Cross and Red Crescent movements, and their partners, to reduce the impacts of climate change and extreme climatic events on the most vulnerable populations.

The Centre brings together climate specialists and offers advice and strategic research work. The Centre’s research is based on the knowledge and support of the national societies of the Red Cross and Red Crescent, the IFRC and the ICRC. Moreover, the Centre works with a large network of humanitarian partners and climate specialists.

To find out more, you can consult the annual report, available here.

Finally, Benoit Hazard mentioned the capacity of local populations, which depend on natural resources, to adapt. Taking the example of East Africa, he recalled their capacity to reconvert and adapt. One of the major challenges according to him is therefore to take into account the consequences of aid programmes, and integrate their capacities and resources for adaptation. In this context, he warned against the destructuring effects which certain programmes can have on social relations and resource management. There is, according to him, an important anthropological reflection to be carried out, which could benefit development practices and humanitarian aid.

To see the full conference, click here, and for more videos visit our YouTube channel.

Translated from the French by Juliet POWYS

   [ + ]

1. In 2016, Humanitarian Alternatives endeavoured to analyse how humanitarian aid substituted for political weaknesses in the face of forced migrations (to see the full conference, click here) and the French Red Cross Fund organised a conference on insurance against risks of cataclysms and disasters of all kinds (Insurance against the risk of crisis: a path towards humanitarian transition?” To see the full conference, click here).
2. http://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar5/wg1/index_fr.shtml

194 thoughts on “The impacts of climate change on poverty and humanitarian crises: what observations and proposals from civil society?

  1. Pingback: sildenafil viagra vardenafil levitra and tadalafil cialis

  2. Pingback: cialis prices walmart

  3. Pingback: best canadian prescription prices

  4. Pingback: canadian drugstore online

  5. Pingback: plaquenil guidelines 2018

  6. Pingback: paxil 10mg

  7. Pingback: metformin causing diarrhea

  8. Pingback: neurontin and ibuprofen

  9. Pingback: cialis super active 20mg pills

  10. Pingback: step sister viagra redtube

  11. Pingback: cheaper viagra pill

  12. Pingback: cialis without perscriptions

  13. Pingback: best viagra pills

  14. Pingback: testimonios sobre el uso de cialis

  15. Pingback: chinese cialis

  16. Pingback: best over counter viagra

  17. Pingback: cialis dosages

  18. Pingback: cialis contraindications

  19. Pingback: cialis super active plus

  20. Pingback: where can i find someone to write my college paper

  21. Pingback: best article writing service

  22. Pingback: propecia com

  23. Pingback: custom essay writing service

  24. Pingback: write my essay generator

  25. Pingback: phd thesis help

  26. Pingback: dissertation services

  27. Pingback: college admission essay service

  28. Pingback: master thesis writing service

  29. Pingback: buy cheap essays online

  30. Pingback: viagra dick

  31. Pingback: synthroid food interactions

  32. Pingback: generic cialis canada

  33. Pingback: diflucan-fluconazole

  34. Pingback: viagra mistake

  35. Pingback: viagra pas cher

  36. Pingback: priligy in usa

  37. Pingback: viagra generic name

  38. Pingback: metformin and clomid

  39. Pingback: prednisolone osteoporosis

  40. Pingback: doxycycline gram negative

  41. Pingback: viagra accident

  42. Pingback: viagra torture

  43. Pingback: levitra vs viagra

  44. Pingback: cialis pills

  45. Pingback: slipped friend viagra

  46. Pingback: cheap viagra online

  47. Pingback: sex with viagra

  48. Pingback: fildena vs viagra

  49. Pingback: combivent brand name

  50. Pingback: where to buy stromectol online

  51. Pingback: azithromycin 100mg tablet

  52. Pingback: lasix online purchase

  53. Pingback: where can you get amoxicillin

  54. Pingback: cialis original for sale

  55. Pingback: find cheap cialis online

  56. Pingback: essay on issue business ethics theories

  57. Pingback: help me write a narrative essay

  58. Pingback: cialis original for sale

  59. Pingback: write my essay help

  60. Pingback: writing a research proposal

  61. Pingback: cheap writing service

  62. Pingback: monthly cost of cialis without insurance

  63. Pingback: viagra

  64. Pingback: cialis sale 20mg

  65. Pingback: buy cialis without perscription

  66. Pingback: 100mg viagra

  67. Pingback: cialis tadalafil

  68. Pingback: cialis original for sale

  69. Pingback: deaths from cialis

  70. Pingback: sildenafil prices local pharmacies

  71. Pingback: how do mix azithromycin 200mg/5ml powder for oral suspension

  72. Pingback: cymbalta type i diabetes

  73. Pingback: waar is viagra voor

  74. Pingback: buy cialis online generic

  75. Pingback: how viagra works

  76. Pingback: natural alternative to keflex

  77. Pingback: celecoxib with excedrin

  78. Pingback: ldeqiibd

  79. Pingback: azithromycin tab 250mg

  80. Pingback: buy cialis 36 hour

  81. Pingback: buy cialis drug

  82. Pingback: amoxicillin side effects in dogs

  83. Pingback: cymbalta and drinking

  84. Pingback: buy cialis tadalafil0 with pay pal

  85. Pingback: keflex side effects in elderly

  86. Pingback: generic cialis 20 mg tadalafil

  87. Pingback: celebrex and sulfa allergy

  88. Pingback: zithromax shelf life

  89. Pingback: amoxicillin for sinus infection dosage

  90. Pingback: viagra in mexico over the counter

  91. Pingback: cialis for sale in toronto

  92. Pingback: where can i buy cialis without a prescription

  93. Pingback: cialis 5mg 10mg no prescription

  94. Pingback: generic cialis daily pricing

  95. Pingback: buy cialis online viagra

  96. Pingback: super strength cialis

  97. Pingback: cialis 20mg low price

  98. Pingback: cialis uk

  99. Pingback: does 20mg cialis work

  100. Pingback: viagra conenct

  101. Pingback: shop cialis generic

  102. Pingback: cheap viagra without a doctor prescription

  103. Pingback: 100 milligrams viagra

  104. Pingback: cialis soft vs cialis

  105. Pingback: viagra pills for sale

  106. Pingback: cialis professional

  107. Pingback: incest viagra

  108. Pingback: free viagra coupons

  109. Pingback: discount cialis

  110. Pingback: cialis generic canada

  111. Pingback: citalopram hydrochloride

  112. Pingback: how long for celebrex to work

  113. Pingback: coreg strengh

  114. Pingback: buspar and weight gain

  115. Pingback: buspar and mobic

  116. Pingback: viagra

  117. Pingback: pristiq and wellbutrin

  118. Pingback: baclofen use with peptic ulcer disease

  119. Pingback: faa baclofen

  120. Pingback: Grifulvin V

  121. Pingback: Dulcolax

  122. Pingback: the peoples pharmacy

  123. Pingback: azithromycin dose pack

  124. Pingback: approved canadian pharmacies online

  125. Pingback: atorvastatin free

  126. Pingback: Nortriptyline

  127. Pingback: abilify 300 mg

  128. Pingback: should you take amoxicillin with food

  129. Pingback: amlodipine swollen ankles

  130. Pingback: amitriptyline hcl 25 mg wtih alcohol

  131. Pingback: amiodarone fa davis

  132. Pingback: allopurinol zyloprim

  133. Pingback: aripiprazole 5mg tablets

  134. Pingback: can tizanidine be taken with gabepentin

  135. Pingback: womens viagra

  136. Pingback: how long does viagra take to work

  137. Pingback: how long does viagra stay in your system

  138. Pingback: what does viagra do

  139. Pingback: oxybutynin hypotension

  140. Pingback: ciprofloxacin 500 for dogs

  141. Pingback: cialis for women

  142. Pingback: cialis price

  143. Pingback: tadalafil for sale

  144. Pingback: cialis without a doctor prescription

  145. Pingback: what is in keflex antibiotic

  146. Pingback: write my essay please

  147. Pingback: buying viagra

  148. Pingback: cialis pills for sale

  149. Pingback: revatio vs viagra

  150. Pingback: augmentin kidney function

  151. Pingback: viagra naturale

  152. Pingback: cialis with prozac

  153. Pingback: writing a thesis paragraph

  154. Pingback: what is thesis in writing

  155. Pingback: viagra professional generic

  156. Pingback: help on research papers

  157. Pingback: someone write my paper for me

  158. Pingback: doctoral dissertation database

  159. Pingback: https://customessaywriterbyz.com

  160. Pingback: help with writing essays at university

  161. Pingback: https://essaywritingservicesjy.com

  162. Pingback: cialis vasocostrittore

  163. Pingback: free samples of viagra

  164. Pingback: i need help writing a narrative essay

  165. Pingback: how to use viagra

  166. Pingback: viagra dosing

  167. Pingback: what is viagra

  168. Pingback: atorvastatin ckd

  169. Pingback: cialis soft

  170. Pingback: where can i buy levitra online

  171. Pingback: viagra sample

  172. Pingback: generic tadalafil

  173. Pingback: viagra for men over 60

  174. Pingback: viagra pill

  175. Pingback: cialis coupons

  176. Pingback: marley generic viagra

  177. Pingback: buy cialis usa

  178. Pingback: what is female viagra

  179. Pingback: viagra walmart

  180. Pingback: viagra 100mg

  181. Pingback: viagra pills generic

  182. Pingback: side effects cialis

  183. Pingback: natural viagra

  184. Pingback: cialis online

  185. Pingback: generic for cialis

  186. Pingback: cialis without prescriptions

  187. Pingback: generic cialis

  188. Pingback: cialis

  189. Pingback: generic cialis

  190. Pingback: viagra generic

  191. Pingback: buy cialis tadalafil

  192. Pingback: mom gives son viagra

  193. Pingback: generic viagra

  194. Pingback: cialis otc

Comments are closed.